Cookie Exchange Party Ideas and Tips | Walking on Sunshine (2024)

We all want to be successful when hosting a Cookie Exchange Party. Today I am sharing with you a few of my cookie party ideas for large groups and small groups.

This post is packed with expert tips and tricks to help you host a successful event that will be truly memorable. Plus, there are FREE printables to help you invite your family and friends in style!

Don't miss out on this ultimate guide to creating the perfect event and treat your guests to a delightful and delicious experience!

Check out all the otherChristmas Cookiesfor more delicious ideas and recipes that are perfect for the holiday season.

Have you ever hosted a cookie exchange party? Hosting a cookie exchange party can be a lot of work while at the same time a lot of fun.

Why not plan one this holiday season with a few of your friends? After you read through this post, check out my Best Christmas Cookies for a collection of over 50 recipes that would be perfect to bring to an cookie swap over the holidays.

Looking for moreChristmas Cookie ideas and recipes?Try myChocolate Christmas Cookies,Reindeer Dessertsor myChristmas Refrigerator Cookies.

What is a Cookie Exchange Party?

A cookie exchange party, also referred to as a cookie swap, is an event where friends, family, or colleagues come together to share and trade homemade cookies.

Each guest bakes a certain amount of one kind of cookie and brings them to the party. At the event, cookies are showcased on a table, and guests can taste different types and pack a variety to take home.

Cookie exchange parties are an enjoyable way to sample various cookies without the need to bake them all on your own. They also provide a chance to socialize, exchange recipes, and spread holiday cheer.

Cookie Exchange Invitations

When it comes to invitations for a cookie exchange party, there are various options to choose from. You can purchase invitations online from Amazon.

If you're feeling crafty, consider making your own DIY invitations. Or take advantage of the FREE Printable Christmas Cookie Exchange Party Printables I have for you to use.

Click on the photo or sign up in the box at the bottom of the post and the invitations will be sent to your email address for you to download, print and use!

How to do a Cookie Exchange with a Large Group?

Here are a few cookie exchange party ideas to help you have a fun and successful party:

• Decide on how many guests you want to invite. The bigger your guest list is, the more baking everyone has to do.
• Last year I went to an insanely big Christmas Cookie Exchange Party. I baked close to 300 cookies; but I also came home with an incredible amount of cookies that I was able to use for most all my Christmas entertaining.
• At the end of the day, it really just depends on how many people you feel comfortable with inviting.

Cookie Exchange Rules

• Homemade Cookies. Everyone should bake the cookies they are bringing.
• Give an exact number of cookies that everyone needs to bring. The few cookie exchange parties I have been to, the host let us know at least a week or so before the party how many cookies we needed to bake and bring with us.
• A good rule of thumb is to ask everyone to bring a dozen cookies per guest invited. So if you have invited six guests, as each one to bring 72 cookies.
• Have everyone bring a copy of their cookie recipe. That way everyone goes home with recipes to add to their recipe box.
• It's helpful to label cookies with their name or flavor. This makes it easier for guests to identify the cookies.

Have your Guests Bring a Copy of their Recipe

Ask each guest to bring their recipe written out on recipe cards to include with each package of cookies they bring for the exchange. Here's a cute FREE Printable Christmas Cookie Exchange Party Printables for you to use and share with your guests.

When to Bake your Cookies

Now that you have the rules and cookie exchange party ideas in place, let's talk cookies!

Try to have your cookies baked a few days before the exchange. You don't want to be up late the night before baking 72 or more cookies. Trust me, that's what I did one year andmy husband had to help as it became obvious I wasn't ever going to finish baking cookies!

It helps to plan ahead and maybe choose a cookie that can be frozen.Check out my Freezer Friendly Slice and Bake Cookies and read up on a few tips on How to Freeze Cookie Dough from my blog.

Christmas Cookie Digital Cookbook BUNDLE with FREE Cookie Exchange Printables BonusMore Information

Ask your Guests to Bring a Tray of Cookies

In addition to the cookies your guests are preparing to exchange, why not ask them to bring a tray of cookies for everyone to enjoy? This works especially well if you're also planning on hosting a delightful brunch or a satisfying light lunch.

You can use the trays of cookies for dessert. I set up a separate dessert buffet table for guests to place their cookie trays on when they arrive.

Cookie Exchange Packaging Ideas

Your guests will need a way to bring home all the cookies. There are many great ideas that you can find online at Amazon or at your local Dollar Tree Store.

• Cellophane Bags with Ribbon.
• Mason Jars are a really fun and creative way for your guests to package their cookies.
• Decorative Cookie Tins - when I think of Christmas cookies, I always think of the pretty cookie tins my mother would pull out to store all the cookies she would bake.
• Gift Bags with Tags

More InformationMore InformationMore InformationMore InformationMore InformationMore Information

What to Serve at a Cookie Exchange Party?

Enjoy the time catching up with your friends as you all enjoy something yummy to eat. You can either provide all the food yourself or you can have everyone bring a dish to share.

Here are a few ideas from my Christmas Breakfast Recipes index:

• Christmas Tree Cheese Board - this is such a cute way to serve cheese to your guests.
• Candy Cane Danish - I made this recipe one year for a cookie exchange and it looked so great on the buffet table.
• Mini Pizza Appetizers - I love using cookie cutters to make cute individual sized pizzas when I'm hosting a cookie exchange. Everyone loves them and they turn out great!
• Christmas Tree Cream Cheese Danish - this recipe is really easy to make and looks so cute sitting on the buffet.

Set up a Hot Cocoa Bar

Cookies always taste better with hot cocoa, right? Here's a fun idea that we did at one of our cookie exchange parties a few years ago.

Cookie Exchange Games

Cookie exchange games are a fun way to engage guests and add excitement to your cookie exchange party. Included in the free party invitations are also voting cards so everyone can vote for the best cookie, most creative and a few other ideas.

You can also play a fun "Guess who made the Cookie." This game involves people trying to guess which guest made which cookie. It helps break the ice and encourages conversation among guests.

How to do a Cookie Swap Party?

After you spend a little time socializing with your friends, have each guest talk about the cookie recipe they brought with them.

Some ladies like to make a recipe that was their grandmother's favorite and have a lovely story to tell. Take the time to swap the cookies with each other and enjoy sampling everyone's cookies!